A student asked me a question and I have no good answer for him. Can you help?
He had written "They also enable your business become more efficient."
I corrected this by inserting 'to'. Perhaps I am wrong to do so, but that sentence sounds very iffy to me.
He said that he had been told that:
"He helped him become a doctor."
"He helped him to become a doctor."
were both correct. I agreed.
What he would like is some rule to follow and I can't supply one.
I have been teaching in Serbia for 8 months and I'm an Englishman.
Thanks for any help in advance.
Ben
to become or not become
Moderator: Joe
-
- Member
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Sat May 09, 2015 10:08 am
- Status: New Teacher
Re: to become or not become
Hi Ben,
Enable someone to do something: there is always the 'to' in this phrase.
Enable someone to do something: there is always the 'to' in this phrase.
Take a look at Lucy Pollard's Guide to Teaching English
- cerealkillah
- Prolific Member
- Posts: 45
- Joined: Sat Feb 08, 2014 10:28 am
- Status: Teacher
Re: to become or not become
I agree with Susan.
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/diction ... ish/enable
"Help" requires either full infinitive or bare infinitive.
"enable" is used with full infinitive.
http://dictionary.cambridge.org/diction ... ish/enable
"Help" requires either full infinitive or bare infinitive.
"enable" is used with full infinitive.
-
- Member
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Sat May 09, 2015 10:08 am
- Status: New Teacher
Re: to become or not become
Thank you for your responses, Susan and Serial Killer.
The only verbs I can find that take the bare infinitive are modals, 'did' and 'help'.
I should make the bed.
I must make the bed
I did make the bed.
I helped make the bed.
But
I want to make the bed.
I attempted to make the bed.
I have concluded that the rule I'm seeking is 'only after modals, did and help'
Do you concur, or are there other verbs lurking in the undergrowth that also take the bare infinitive or, as in the case of 'help', take both? A fellow teacher and I simply couldn't come up with any.
Thanks once again.
Ben.
The only verbs I can find that take the bare infinitive are modals, 'did' and 'help'.
I should make the bed.
I must make the bed
I did make the bed.
I helped make the bed.
But
I want to make the bed.
I attempted to make the bed.
I have concluded that the rule I'm seeking is 'only after modals, did and help'
Do you concur, or are there other verbs lurking in the undergrowth that also take the bare infinitive or, as in the case of 'help', take both? A fellow teacher and I simply couldn't come up with any.
Thanks once again.
Ben.
- cerealkillah
- Prolific Member
- Posts: 45
- Joined: Sat Feb 08, 2014 10:28 am
- Status: Teacher
Re: to become or not become
Not only for modals, I'm afraid. Make is another verb that takes the bare infinitive, but you have to be careful about the passive voice:
He made me do the washing up.
I was made to do the washing up.
What's more, there are also verbs related to senses, which can take either bare infinitive or gerund form (with a slight change of meaning):
I saw my brother cross the street.
I saw my brother crossing the street.
Then, there's also the subjunctive...
He made me do the washing up.
I was made to do the washing up.
What's more, there are also verbs related to senses, which can take either bare infinitive or gerund form (with a slight change of meaning):
I saw my brother cross the street.
I saw my brother crossing the street.
Then, there's also the subjunctive...